DoIT Showroom Buyer's Guide


 ADVANCED

Apple vs Dell Comparison


This document is geared at understanding the differences between Mac and Windows computers.

The University does not recommend one platform over another. DoIT provides extensive support for both PCs and Macs and their software. When making your decision, a good rule of thumb is to "go with what you know." A student faces many new challenges when starting college; it's probably a good idea not to add the effort of learning a new operating system. Here are some other issues to consider.

Usage Areas - PCs are generally used in the business, legal, and engineering fields. Macs tend to be found in the art, video production and web design fields. Although this is not always the case, and as time progresses there is more of a crossover between the two operating systems in various areas of study. DoIT recommends contacting your intended field of study if you are concerned. Apple computers with an Intel Processor can also have Windows installed on them if you need to run any programs that require Windows or provide more features than their Mac version. For more information see: Running Windows on Macs.

DoIT Recommendations - Macs and PCs use different operating systems so it's hard to compare from one platform to the other. We recommend coming in, trying each machine to see which one fits you better. DoIT also recommends not changing platforms unless you have a reason to do so.

Market share - While PCs outnumber Macs in the general public and on campus, Macs have experienced a significant increase in market share, especially on campus.

Software - The latest Microsoft Office products (Office 2007 for Windows and Office 2008 for Mac) are available for $72 through our campus Microsoft Contract. These latest versions employ a new file format which cannot be read by earlier verisons of Microsoft Office without installing the appropriate free updates from Microsoft. Comparable versions of Microsoft Office are cross-platform, allowing file transfer back and forth between Macs and PCs. For more details on compatibility see: Microsoft Office 2008 File Format Converter for 2004 and Office 2007 Compatibility Issues.

For $72, Office 2008 for Mac includes:

For $72, Office 2007 Enterprise for PC includes: You can purchase these Office products and other specially priced software in person at the DoIT Tech Store or online at the Wisconsin Integrated Software Catalog (WISC) site.

Price and Feature Comparison Example:

Apple systems have always been thought of as more expensive, partly because of smaller market share and higher profit margins. Recently, Apple's laptops in particular have come down in price to match more closely with Dell's education prices. Below is a chart comparing the standard recommended laptops, configured as closely as possible.

System

Dell Inspiron 1420

Dell Studio XPS M1340

Apple MacBook

Apple 13 in. MacBook Pro
Price $1149.99 $1399.00
Processor 2.4 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo 2.53 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo
Memory 4 GB DDR3 4GB DDR3
Screen 13.3-inch widescreen WXGA LCD
(1280x800)
13.3-inch widescreen WXGA LCD
(1280x800)
Hard Drive 320GB 250GB
Optical Drive DVD Burner DVD Burner (SuperDrive)
Communications Gigabit ethernet, 802.11n wireless, Bluetooth *No 56k modem Gigabit ethernet, 802.11n wireless, Bluetooth, *No 56k modem
(optional $44 purchase at DoIT Techstore)
Connectivity USB 2.0, Firewire, e-SATA, HDMI, WebCam USB 2.0, Firewire, SD Card Slot, iSight WebCam,
Warranty 3 Year Limited Warranty plus 3 Year InHome Service and 3 Year Accidental Damage (CompleteCare) with LoJack Theft Protection 1 Year Limited Warranty (extendable to 3 Years with purchase of AppleCare for $183)

Operating System

Windows Vista Home Premium Mac OS X 10.6 (Snow Leopard)
Software Microsoft Works, Roxio Creator 10 Dell Edition, Adobe Reader 9, McAfee SecurityCenter with anti-virus, anti-spyware, firewall, 15 months iLife (iTunes, iPhoto, iMovie HD, GarageBand, iDVD, iWeb)
Mail and iCal
Size / Weight 1.33" thick; 12.56"x 9.3"
4.85+ lbs
.95" thick; 12.78"x 8.94"
4.5 lbs

File compatibility

Exchanging documents and files between a PC and a Mac is not a problem as the long as the program used to create the file has an equivalent Mac and PC version. Products like Boot Camp, Parallels and VMware Fusion allow your Mac to run a Windows operating system and software programs written for Windows. For more information: Buying a Windows Operating System for Use on an Apple Computer.

The technology

Both platforms are reliable, although the prospective PC buyer should always do some checking before selecting from the large number of PC manufacturers. DoIT Repair and Desktop Support is certified to perform warranty repairs on both Dells and Apples. Although they can also handle repairs on other manufacturers of PCs, they cannot honor those manufacturer's warranties.

Variety of choices

PCs are made by many companies and are available everywhere. That gives you a broad set of choices and lets you mix and match to meet your needs. The Mac comes from one vendor, Apple. For more help in identifying a computer to fit your needs, contact the DoIT Showroom at 265-7469; showroom@doit.wisc.edu

See Also:




Keywords: personal departmental apple dell incoming freshmen freshman student new computerDoc ID: 3045
Owner: Leo L.Group: Showroom
Created: 2004-07-23Updated: 2009-09-09

Did this document help you to answer your question?